Editorial
Too Local to Fail
The state built a brewery a $7 million building and rents it for $500 a month. The Gazette proposes the same terms for everyone.
PROVIDENCE — This summer a pavilion opened in 195 District Park, on the river beside the pedestrian bridge: six sides, cedar shiplap, glass doors that fold open to the water. The building cost $7 million, according to the Providence Eye, $4 million of it from the 2021 Beach, Clean Water and Green Bond and $3 million from the state's capital fund. The I-195 Redevelopment District Commission's draft audit carries the whole project at $8.7 million.
The tenant is The Guild, a Pawtucket brewery, with Seven Stars Bakery on coffee. The Guild pays $500 a month in base rent, plus 8 percent of beer sales and 4 percent of food, the Eye reported.
A restaurant's fixed costs are the building and the rent. Here the public paid for the first and set the second at $500. Everything else the landlord collects is a share of what gets sold, so when sales fall the rent falls with them, and the landlord takes the slow months too. The terms leave very little to fail with.
In 2008 the country learned to object when the public stood behind a firm's losses because the firm was too big. The pavilion extends the same courtesy on the grounds that the firm is local. At the ribbon cutting in April, the Speaker said the Green Bond would "showcase some of the local businesses that make the Ocean State's hospitality industry so exceptional," and the governor said the pavilion would be a place "where small businesses can grow and thrive." The river has run on a version of this for years. After each WaterFire lighting the city sweeps the streets, $3,472.59 for the six lightings of 2025 by its own records, and the evening belongs to whoever is selling along the water.
The Gazette sees no reason these terms should be limited to one brewery. It proposes the Infinite Lease Program: every Rhode Islander receives a $7 million building on the pavilion's terms, $500 a month and 8 percent of whatever they sell, on a lease that does not end. At about 1.1 million residents the program costs roughly $7.7 trillion, a little more than the federal government spent in fiscal 2025. The 2021 bond, all $74 million of it, covers the first ten and a half buildings.
The program also settles the state's labor question. By this paper's count, Rhode Island's three leading occupations are saying things, standing around, and selling overpriced stuff. The first two need no building. The pavilion already staffs all three: five officials said things at the ribbon cutting, the brewery's co-founder counts 5,000 people a day crossing the bridge next door, winter and summer, and the third occupation is the one the building was built for. Under the program every resident gets a building, and with it a place in the third.
In reality the state's growth job is a different one. Electric Boat expects to hire 3,500 people at Quonset Point this year, building sections of the Navy's nuclear submarines, the Columbia class among them, which will carry the country's sea-launched nuclear missiles. That enterprise is actually too big to fail. Nobody has proposed building it a pavilion.
The program has one early participant. Pat the manatee washed up this week beside Sandy Beaches, of the Nothing desk, and is lying there, enormous, motionless and gazing, apparently infinitely. Pat has not applied and has not been asked for rent. The Gazette considers the terms met.